The reds, the blues or the greens?

Posted by Andrew Wadge on August 22nd 2007 in General interest

Today my eye was caught by a very attractive photograph of berries in an article in the Daily Telegraph, telling us: ‘If it’s purple, black or blue – eat it.’

Although the article says ‘no one is suggesting that we ditch all the rest of the fruit and veg, it’s just that simply eating your greens [isn’t enough]', it’s easy to see how a member of the public could be misled when it goes on to present a week’s worth of menus based almost entirely on these colours of fruit and veg.

This is just one amidst a flurry of articles on a recent laboratory study that shows the possible power of the natural pigment in red, purple and blue foods, such as radishes and aubergines. Rich in anthocyanins, the pigment in these foods has been shown to slow the growth of colon cancer cells in the test tube.

Yesterday, again in the Daily Telegraph, Dr Greg Martin, Head of Science and Research at the World Cancer Research Fund, presented a balanced view about the new research. His letter quite rightly suggested ‘before we all throw away our greens and rush out to stock up on aubergines and red cabbage, we should remember it is only one study’.

I have blogged before on the potential confusion that can be caused by the constant and often simplistic reporting of scientific research; the effect of which can be to undermine official advice on diet and health.

In this case, the straightforward advice is to eat a variety of fruit and veg every day rather than supporting just the reds or the blues, or even the greens – healthy eating shouldn’t be about taking sides.

Red for danger etc

Posted by Andrew Wadge on 06/09/2007 - 13:15

Thanks to all for commenting and for the very good points made. You're right, care does need to be taken. We do have some advice actually on foraging for berries and other hedgerow foods. Check it out on our eatwell website

Colours of food

Posted by Jo Newbould. M.Sc. (not verified) on 02/09/2007 - 22:18

It should be made clear that NOT ALL Red or Purple Berries are good, for instance the RED Berries of 'Lords & Ladies' as well as the PURPLE Berries of Solanum species are highly poisonous.

Red for danger.

Posted by Anonymous (not verified) on 25/08/2007 - 09:07

Surely someone should point out to the general public that not ALL berries of the colours indicated are safe to eat. Where there are now TV programmes encouraging the picking of wayside berries etc, somewhere there should be adequate warnings against such berries as for instance yew,lovely and red, but highly poisonous.

Reds, Blues and Greens

Posted by Anonymous (not verified) on 23/08/2007 - 18:07

Common sense would appear to be in short supply, studies will of course, show that fruits that are black, blue or red are important for our well being as are the green vegetables but nature placed many nutritious crops of varying colours which are also extremely beneficial to us bananas,onions, garlic, herbs, cauliflower,mushrooms not forgetting apples and oranges. Instead of pointing people towards certain colours teach that a good balanced diet containing all of these foods is the aim.